The type of
discussion I have seen in my classroom is I-R-E (initiate, response, evaluate).
This consists of the teacher initiating a topic by asking a question and the
students respond to the question followed by the teacher evaluating the
response and initiating another question. While reading the article, A New View of Discussion, I learned that
this type of traditional discussion is often called recitation. This is due to
the fact that there is no collaborative attempt to construct meaning.
In contrast, response-centered
talk allows students to set the agenda for the discussion and become more
engaged in a conversation with their peers. It consists of a combination of
student’s responses/ thinking and the teacher’s responses/guidance. This is
different compared to the type of discussion I have observed in my classroom
because the teacher actually steps back and let the students talk about what is
on their minds. In addition, the teacher guides the discussion when needed
rather than construct the entire discussion.
In order for
response-centered talk to take place in my classroom the teacher should step
back and allow the students to create their own questions and talk about what
they think. I believe this would work well because all students have their own
opinion and different views. In addition, they interpret stories differently.
If they were able to participate in a response-centered talk I think they would
be more engaged in the conversation because they would be able to discuss
things that they noticed or have questions about.
Response-centered
talk would also be a great way to include students who do not participate
actively. This could be done by creating small groups of no more than 4
students and setting requirements such as each student must contribute 2 things
to the discussion. Also, some students do not actively participate because they
are shy when it comes to speaking up in front of the whole group so using
response-centered talk with small groups would not only allow students to
interpret the meaning of the story on their own, but also make them feel
comfortable within their small group of peers.